Who is Joe Nickell ? The Top page for this discussion. Read this first.

JOE NICKELL  claims vs. proof

You may wish to open Joe Nickell's article in a separate window to compare the text with the comments that follow. Joe Nickell's article is an attack on Raymond Rogers' scientific competence and honesty. Read Rogers' Letter to the Editor of Skeptical Inquirer magazine.

Ray Schneider's Comment on paragraph 2:   In the second paragraph which is a bit more sane -- Nickell calls what Rogers does "claims" and characterizes what the C14 dating labs did proof.  This prejudges the paper, without describing what it contains except in very global terms.  

Go on to read comments on paragraph 3.

Joe Nickell's article is an attack on Raymond Rogers' scientific competence and honesty. Read Rogers' Letter to the Editor of Skeptical Inquirer magazine.

Ray Schneider's Comments on a single page.